Time to stem the tide of successful people leaving Canada

Article content material

There are various profitable Canadians who’re exploring or outright leaving this country. Dependable statistics are laborious to come back by, however tax practitioners akin to myself have been saved very busy as a result of financial and taxation insurance policies matter, particularly the messaging surrounding such insurance policies.

Within the first 23 years of my profession, I labored on roughly a dozen “departure tax” circumstances. Departure tax is the lingo that’s utilized in my occupation since a deemed disposition of 1’s property will instantly happen earlier than an individual turns into a non-resident of Canada, thus inflicting taxation (there are a number of exceptions to this common rule). However the variety of recordsdata that my colleagues and I’ve labored on up to now 9 years has skyrocketed into the a whole lot.

Article content material

It began with one of many new Liberal authorities’s first bulletins in November 2015 that it might be “asking the rich to pay just a bit bit extra” by introducing a brand new top-end private tax bracket that elevated the earlier highest charge by 4 proportion factors. This measure boosted many provinces’ most mixed federal-provincial private tax charges to roughly 54 per cent.

To be truthful, not all the brand new recordsdata we labored on resulted in folks leaving Canada, however many individuals in the end did and the remaining needed to know their choices. Suffice it to say that the wealth related to such recordsdata is very large.

The willpower of whether or not or not an individual is or turns into a non-resident of Canada for tax functions could be very a lot a query that requires cautious evaluation. Intention just isn’t all that determinative. In different phrases, you may need the intention of being a non-resident of Canada for tax functions, however your details higher make it so. Accordingly, it takes cautious planning to grow to be a non-resident of Canada for tax functions.

As soon as an individual turns into a non-resident, that individual is then solely topic to Canadian tax on their Canadian-sourced earnings, akin to tendencies of Canadian actual property, employment exercised in Canada, carrying on a enterprise in Canada and sure withholding taxes on Canadian-sourced dividends, royalties, rents, and so forth.

Article content material

Article content material

Relying on the individual’s state of affairs and given Canada’s comparatively excessive private tax charges, the long run tax financial savings for a lot of profitable folks — even when factoring within the one-time departure tax — may be great. Not all the time, clearly.

Why are many profitable — and more and more youthful — Canadians occupied with exploring turning into non-residents? Nicely, there are a lot of causes, together with life-style, the cost of living and higher job markets and alternatives elsewhere.

Tax can be a problem. Our nation’s private tax charges are punishingly excessive and rising, with the current capital gains inclusion rate hike and amendments to the Alternative Minimum Tax. Capital could be very fluid, so lots of the folks leaving merely deploy their capital elsewhere. Clearly, it’s not that straightforward for some.

Total, although, the most important reason for profitable folks leaving is that they really feel that they’re being attacked in their very own nation and are usually not appreciated for all their contributions. Nearly all of the recordsdata that my colleagues and I’ve labored on up to now 9 years have concerned very proud and patriotic Canadians. Lots of them are neighborhood leaders and really philanthropic, each with their cash and their time.

Article content material

Insurance policies that assault the very core of who they’re make it seem to be a long-term relationship that has turned sideways. The primary assault was on Dec. 7, 2015, when the federal government increased personal tax rates for the “wealthy” (efficient from 2016 ahead). Huh? Weren’t they already contributing quite a bit?

Subsequent was the brutal assault on small-business homeowners by introducing draconian taxation proposals on July 18, 2017. The messaging surrounding these proposals brought on vital backlash, which the federal government doubled down on for months by utilizing much more mindless rhetoric. Overly simplified, the messaging concerning these proposals said that many small-business homeowners have been basically “tax cheats.” Not good.

This was adopted by the COVID-19 interval of limitless and breathless spending by the federal government, with steady articles being printed about how that point might be used for a “reset.” Radical concepts such because the doable introduction of a wealth tax, windfall taxes and different mindless concepts have been constantly floated by authorities operatives and their supporters.

Article content material

The current introduction of the capital positive factors inclusion charge hike recycled the federal government’s assault on the wealthy by asking them to pay extra and saying it might solely apply to 0.13 per cent of Canadians (an outright deceptive assertion).

The most recent assault is on older Canadians who’ve owned their properties and been lucky sufficient to have capital appreciation. The federal government has been cozying up to organizations that imagine these older Canadians ought to pay a house fairness tax in sure circumstances. It’s apparent the federal government is exploring many concepts associated to elevating tax revenues as a way to help its bloated spending.

The above record is clearly incomplete, however the image being painted is apparent. Profitable Canadians who are usually not feeling appreciated for his or her years of laborious work, dangers taken, jobs created, philanthropy, and so forth., and are always attacked are going to cope with it a method or one other. At that time, feelings, quite than mind, take over.

The insurance policies and the messaging from the federal government stir these inevitable feelings. Consequently, the acceleration of profitable Canadians leaving will proceed till the ugly politics, insurance policies and divisive messaging decline.

Article content material

Canada wants a return to unifying messaging from the federal government. This could embrace the introduction of fine financial and taxation insurance policies that encourage, help and reward folks to take dangers. And the small variety of risk-takers who in the end grow to be profitable should be celebrated with optimistic messaging, not harmful and divisive rhetoric.

Such a change would possibly simply stem the tide of profitable Canadians trying elsewhere.

Kim Moody, FCPA, FCA, TEP, is the founding father of Moodys Tax/Moodys Non-public Consumer, a former chair of the Canadian Tax Basis, former chair of the Society of Property Practitioners (Canada) and has held many different management positions within the Canadian tax neighborhood. He may be reached at kgcm@kimgcmoody.com and his LinkedIn profile is https://www.linkedin.com/in/kimgcmoody.

_____________________________________________________________

If you happen to like this story, join the FP Investor E-newsletter.

_____________________________________________________________

Bookmark our web site and help our journalism: Don’t miss the enterprise information that you must know — add financialpost.com to your bookmarks and join our newsletters here.

Article content material