Unreported capital gain on home flipped 8 years ago dings taxpayer

Article content material

To discourage hypothesis within the housing market, the 2022 federal budget launched anti-flipping guidelines for residential real estate (together with rental properties) that got here into impact Jan. 1, 2023, and have been designed to “scale back speculative demand within the market and assist to chill extreme worth progress.”

The foundations stop you from claiming the principal residence exemption to shelter the capital gain realized on the sale of your own home in the event you’ve owned it for lower than 12 months, and so they tax the achieve on the sale of any residential actual property as 100 per cent taxable enterprise revenue, topic to sure exemptions for all times occasions resembling loss of life, incapacity, separation and work relocation.

Article content material

Though the principles solely got here into play for 2023 and future years, the Canada Revenue Agency can nonetheless problem actual property “flips” that befell previous to 2023 if it feels a taxpayer has speculated and flipped a property for a fast revenue.

Take the case determined final month that concerned an Alberta taxpayer who was reassessed for his 2016 taxation yr for failing to report the revenue he made on the disposition of a property in Calgary.

In 2016, the taxpayer was an actual property affiliate who was concerned in numerous property transactions. One of many properties he owned was a two-bedroom, one-bathroom bungalow with a indifferent two-car storage, which the taxpayer held from Oct. 20, 2016, to Nov. 21, 2016 — a interval of 33 days. Throughout this time, the taxpayer by no means listed the property for hire and he ended up promoting the property for a achieve of almost $73,000, which he didn’t report on his 2016 private tax return.

As a result of the CRA solely reassessed the taxpayer for the unreported 2016 sale in 2021, the primary challenge earlier than the Tax Court docket was whether or not the company was permitted to reassess him past the traditional three-year reassessment interval. To take action, the CRA should typically show, on a steadiness of possibilities, {that a} taxpayer made a misrepresentation attributable to “neglect, carelessness or willful default or dedicated fraud” in submitting their tax return.

Article content material

Article content material

On this case, the CRA wasn’t alleging that the taxpayer dedicated fraud, however the company felt there was a cloth misrepresentation on the taxpayer’s 2016 tax return because the achieve wasn’t reported.

The taxpayer stated he didn’t declare the property sale on his return as a result of his “bills have erased any attainable achieve,” however the decide wasn’t shopping for that rationalization and stated “a misrepresentation was clearly made” when the taxpayer filed his 2016 return, and it was executed “by negligence or at the very least carelessness or wilful default.” Thus, the CRA was permitted to reassess the taxpayer’s 2016 tax yr past the traditional reassessment interval.

In courtroom, the taxpayer stated that, on the very least, he must be entitled to capital positive factors remedy, which means that solely 50 per cent of the achieve is taxable. (For people, the capital positive factors inclusion fee is ready to extend to two-thirds for positive factors of greater than $250,000 on or after June 25, 2024.)

The taxpayer additionally stated his achieve must be diminished to $12,467 (from $73,000) to keep in mind two further bills that he launched as proof on the listening to. The primary was a referral charge of $40,500 paid to an Alberta numbered firm that the taxpayer owned 50-50 together with his enterprise associate, and the second was a referral charge of $20,000 paid to his associate’s partner. Each referral charges have been paid in reference to the sale of the property, he stated.

Article content material

The decide, nonetheless, was not satisfied that, “on the steadiness of possibilities,” the extra $60,500 of bills have been appropriately deducible towards the achieve. “The paperwork are far too ambiguous, imprecise, unclear and unreliable as to the true nature of the funds made at closing,” he stated in disallowing the bills.

The remaining challenge relating to the sale of the property was whether or not the $73,000 achieve was to be taxed as a capital achieve or revenue. As a result of the taxpayer didn’t report the disposition in any respect in his 2016 tax return, the courtroom was compelled to solely depend on the proof introduced at trial to find out whether or not the revenue account remedy alleged by the CRA ought to stand. On this level, the taxpayer didn’t elaborate, besides to keep up that he needed to hire out the property.

However the decide, citing the financing construction used to buy the property, the circumstances main the taxpayer to purchase it within the first place, the “rapid and immediate renovation” of the principle flooring and the basement, and the taxpayer’s expertise as an actual property agent, was not satisfied that the actual intent of the taxpayer when he purchased the property was to hire it out.

Article content material

“The courtroom finds it laborious to imagine that the (taxpayer) was confronted with so many occasions in such a brief time frame that the one choice was to promote the property shortly and make a revenue of roughly $70,000, multi functional month of possession,” the decide stated. “The (taxpayer’s) motivations on this undertaking deserve extra credit score.”

In the long run, the decide concluded that the taxpayer’s testimony was inadequate to assist a recharacterization of the achieve realized on the sale of the property as a capital achieve, and upheld the CRA’s reassessment of revenue remedy.

Jamie Golombek, FCPA, FCA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Personal Wealth in Toronto. Jamie.Golombek@cibc.com.

When you appreciated this story, join extra within the FP Investor e-newsletter.

Bookmark our web site and assist our journalism: Don’t miss the enterprise information it is advisable know — add financialpost.com to your bookmarks and join our newsletters here.

Article content material